Updated: February 23 , 2000
Building and Using the Universal Library
The Evergreen State College, Lib 1612
http://www.scn.org/edu/tesc-ds/1999-2000/u-lib/syllabus.html
Syllabus
Winter Quarter, 2000
Wednesdays, 6-10 pm and two Saturdays (January 8 & March 4), 9 am - 5 pm
Program E-Mail distribution address: u-lib@scn.org
Doug Schuler
dschuler@evergreen.edu
Lib 1608A
360.866.6000 ext. 6704
Randy Stilson
stilsonr@evergreen.edu
Room assignment
360.866.6000 ext. 6126
The library has been created by actual necessities in modern civilization. It
is now a necessary unit in the social fabric. Culture must now transcend the
individual for it is essentially a social cumulation of experience whereby the
men of each generation possess potentially at least, all that their predecessors
have ever learned. Books are one social mechanism for preserving the [human]
racial memory and the library one social apparatus for transferring this to the
consciousness of living individuals. Any understanding of society must include
an explanation of this social element and of its function in communal life.
Thus librarianship takes its place among the phenomena to be discussed in any
system of social science.
- Pierce Butler, 1933
Program Themes
Building and Using the Universal Library is a one-quarter program devoted to
the study of the library as a facilitator of human communication. The library
has an exalted place in the narratives of democracy. We will examine its
historical incarnations, its current state, and its extrapolated futures. We
will pay special attention to how libraries (and their human users) might adjust
to meet the needs of a world that is changing due to globalization and new
communication systems.
Suggested (upper division) equivalencies:
2 social science
2 computer science
4 library and information science
Program Components
Seminars
There will be several in-person seminars this quarter. Promoting a "learning
community" is key at Evergreen, and seminars are essential to that goal.
Everybody is expected to participate in the seminars. This means that everybody
needs to be prepared for each seminar: the material must be read and reflected
upon. The goal of the seminar is for everybody to gain a better understanding
of the ideas and the implications of the material that we read. It also means
that people must be aware and supportive of each other. Sometimes it is
appropriate to ask a question, other times it's appropriate to connect two
seemingly disparate ideas or point out a contradiction that exists in the
writings. The most important thing to remember is that the seminar is a
collective experience in which everybody plays a role in developing a successful
session.
On-line Seminars
We will use the on-line seminars to complement (and help us prepare for) the
in-person seminars. Everybody in the program will participate by contributing a
question (by Monday at noon) and a one paragraph response to somebody's question
(by Tuesday at noon) every week using Web Crossing. We will get a Web
Crossing training session early in the quarter.
Readings
There will be weekly reading assignments. The readings will be found in one of
three places:
- In one of our texts (available in Evergreen book store): Word Power issue of
Index on Censorship, March / April, 1999, and Internet Dreams:
Archetypes, Myths, and Metaphors, by Mark Stefik, MIT Press, 1997
- The Universal Library reader (also in Evergreen book store)
- On the web (URLs listed with assignments below)
The reading assignments for the individual weeks are listed in the schedule
below.
Journal Entries
There will be eight one-page "journal entries" which are due every Wednesday
except the first and last Wednesday. These will be in response to a simple
question or statement which will be found in the syllabus. These are not formal
essays -- they're intended to help develop your thoughts -- but they shouldn't
be "throw-away" either. They should be legible and thoughtful.
Research Paper
Each student is expected to complete a research paper, due on March 1. The
topic and possible hypotheses are due on January 19. This paper must be typed
and be a minimum of five pages. Each paper should clearly state the objectives
it is attempting to attain at the beginning of the paper. Remember: It is
recommended that you use quotations and ideas from books, articles, the web,
etc.; this is how we participate in the ongoing human dialogues on issues that
matter. On the other hand, it is not acceptable to use material without
indicating and crediting the source. Some ideas for papers include: threats to
libraries, uses of information, comparisons with other media, new network tools,
what information do we make available and why, new roles for librarians.
Research papers can also have technical themes and approaches.
Field Study
Each student is expected to make two visits to libraries and write a short paper
comparing them. These "libraries" can be just about any place where information
is stored in a way to facilitate its use. In other words, a visit to a museum
would be appropriate as would a visit to a company that makes database
information available for a fee. These visits are set up by students and should
be planned ahead of time. If you're going to talk to somebody who works there,
you should take the time to prepare your questions. Your field study write-up
will be due on the last night of class, March 8.
Computer Fluency
Each student will participate in one of the seven computer fluency components
which are similar to group contracts. There will be time in class to work on
these in class but students will be doing the bulk of the work outside of class.
Each student will select an area of study, identify objectives, and develop a
plan for meeting those objectives.
The seven computer fluency modules are
- Basics (e.g. e-mail and/or browser use)
- JavaScript
- CGI / Perl scripting for the web
- Graphics (e.g. Photoshop)
- Presentation software (e.g. Microsoft Powerpoint)
- Building Web Pages (e.g. HTML, FrontPage, Pagemill, Flash, etc. )
- Networking (e.g. protocols or RFCs)
Statement from group due: January 19
The statement from the group should contain broad aims, strategy, division of
labor, group evaluation technique.
Individual plan due: January 19
The individual plan should contain project component type (Basics, JavaScript,
etc.), task descriptions, dates of relevant events, and how computer fluency
plan will be evaluated.
Mid-term status report: February 9
The mid-term status report should contain description of your progress in
meeting goals. Also discuss any problems and how you expect to overcome them.
Final product due: March 8
The final product should contain evidence that shows how well you met your
goals. For web based projects, please turn in at least a hardcopy of the main
page with the url of the page printed on the top.
Group Project
Each student will participate in a group project (3 - 6 students per group) in
which an issue related to information and communication is critically explored
and evaluated. Technical projects are also possible: a requirements document or
software analysis for a digital library or service, for example. The projects
will be presented on the last or next to the last day of class and will take no
longer than 30 minutes including a five minute question and answer period. A
group project plan consisting of a title, description, tasks and list of members
of the project is due on February 2. Each student will turn in a description of
their role in the project on the last night of class, March 8.
Portfolios
Each student must keep a portfolio of everything that they have done throughout
the quarter. This should be tidy and well-organized. Your name should appear
on the first page. The portfolio will be turned in on the last meeting day of
the program and will be returned at the student evaluation conference. Please
note that the portfolio consists of hard-copy -- it is not "virtual." If part
of your work is on the Internet please turn in one or more printouts based on
the work with the url plainly marked on each page. The portfolio should also
contain a description of your role in the group project. Be sure to consult
your portfolio or make photocopies of any material that you'll need for your
evaluation!
Evaluations
Evaluation conferences should take place the week before the last Wednesday of
class. Each student should bring in a self-evaluation and a faculty evalution
on the proper forms.
Schedule
[1] Wednesday, January 5, 2000 - What is a Library?
Faculty and student introductions, student interest form
Syllabus preview
Student / faculty photos for Web Crossing
History of the Library presentation (Randy)
The (Platonic) Ideal Library Workshop
[2] Saturday, January 8, 2000 - Some Open Questions
Libraries and Computers lecture -- Boolean logic, search engines, etc. (Doug
& Randy) --
Meet in Library reference classroom (in Law section of
Library)
Seminar
Group project topics discussion and workshop
Web Crossing introduction and sign-in
Readings completed:
- Bureaucracy of evil, Peter Morgan [Word Power, pp 73 - 76]
- Barefoot messengers, John Medcalf [Word Power, pp 91 - 93]
- There's no beating that devil, Sonallah Ibrahim [Word Power, pp 59 - 65]
- Evolution of Brainlike Social Organisms, Manfred Kochen, [reader]
Assignments due:
[3] Wednesday, January 12, 2000 - History of the Library
First Computer fluency meeting
Information Interpretation workshop
Readings completed:
- The Origins of Libraries in History of Libraries in The Western World;
chapter 1, Michael H. Harris. [reader]
- European Public Libraries in History of Libraries in the Western World,
Chapter 11, Michael H. Harris. [reader]
- Modern American Libraries in History of Libraries in the Western World,
Chapter 12, Michael H. Harris. [reader]
- The Great Library of Alexandria Burnt: Towards the History of a Symbol, John
Theim. [reader]
- Oration at the beginning of National Library Week in Australia, Anthony
Mason,
http://www-prod.nla.gov.au/nla/staffpaper/mason.html
- Library history in general (provides a short description of other sites
also),
http://www.aber.ac.uk/~tplwww/e/history.html
Assignments due:
- Journal entry #1: Your expectation of the program and your concept of what
libraries are -- and could be -- for society.
- Please bring in a personal document for use in the Information
Interpretation workshop.
[4] Wednesday, January 19, 2000 - Library History (cont.)
Plato Lecture #1 -- Jamie McClelland,
Media Jumpstart and
Paper Tiger Television,
New York City, "Publishing at Society's Margins"
Seminar
Readings completed:
Assignments due:
- Journal entry #2: What questions would you ask and what answers would you
expect to receive in a study of libraries you will be visiting?
[5] Wednesday, January 26, 2000 - Representing Library Resources
Guest lecture: Phil Coombs, state archivist, formerly with state library.
Group project discussion and meetings workshop
Formats and Types of Information Presentation from Scrolls to Digital
Workshop
Readings completed:
- The Pinakes of Callimachus, F. J. Witty. [reader]
- Cataloging and Classification: an Introduction by Lois Mai Chan, [reader]
- Core Metadata workshop,
http://www.oclc.org/~weibel/dc4.html
- Personalized Information Delivery: An Analysis of Information Filtering
Methods, Peter W. Foltz and Susan T. Dumais,
http://www-psych.nmsu.edu/~pfoltz/cacm/cacm.html
- Cataloging Internet Resources: Survey and Prospectus, Eric Jul,
http://www.asis.org/Bulletin/Oct-97/jul.htm
- Preserving the Internet, Brewster Kahle;
http://www.sciam.com/0397issue/0397kahle.html
- The Digital Library Project, volume 1: The World of knowbots" (excerpt),
Robert E. Kahn and Vinton G. Cerf [Internet Dreams, pp ]
Assignments due:
- Journal entry #3: Reflections of readings and lectures to date
[6] Wednesday, February 2, 2000 - Word Power
Computer fluency meeting #2
Interpretation and reliability of information issues
Seminar
Workshop: Internet Library Case Study
Readings completed:
- WORD POWER Introduction [Word Power, pp 28 - 29]
- Hear It Again, Ted Hughes [Word Power, pp 30 - 31]
- Libraries and their ashes, Alberto Manguel [Word Power, pp 32 - 38]
- A benefactor of the library, Ivan Klima [Word Power, pp 39 - 45]
- The vanished library, Luciano Canfora [Word Power, pp 46 - 53]
- Echoes of lost grandeur, Andrew Hammond [Word Power, pp 54 - 58]
- Prisoner AM-8335 and his Library of Lions, Martin Espada [Word Power, pp 66
- 67]
- Cry havoc, Ahdaf Soueif [Word Power, pp 68 - 72]
- The splendour of truth, Michael Walsh [Word Power, pp 77 - 80]
- Suddenly last summer, Iaguba Diallo [Word Power, pp 81 - 83]
- Morning in the library: 1975, Nadine Gordimer [Word Power, pp 84 - 87]
- Marsh's Library, Michael Foley [Word Power, pp 88 - 90]
- Two Poems for the Pen, Wole Soyinka [Word Power, pp 94 - 97]
Assignments due:
- Journal entry #4: Impact of society on libraries
- Group project plan
[7] Wednesday, February 9, 2000 - Transitions
Guest Lecture: Marc Smith, Microsoft Netscan Project, "Virtual Libraries,
Collective Knowledge, and Online Communities"
Readings completed:
- The Roles of Libraries in Access to Networked Information: Cautionary Tales
from the Era of Broadcasting. Clifford Lynch. [reader]
- Electronic Libraries and Electronic Librarians: Who Does What in a National
Electronic Community? Bruce R. Schatz [reader]
- Creating the Library of the Future,
http://www.virtualschool.edu/mon/Academia/HawkinsLibraryOfFuture.html
- What Is the Role of Libraries in the Information Economy? (excerpt), John
Browning [Internet Dreams, pp 55 - 66]
Assignments due:
- Journal entry #5: How will traditional and future libraries become more
disparate? More integrated?
- Computer fluency progress report
[8] Wednesday, February 16, 2000 - The Library and the Community
Lecture on search engine architecture, etc. (Doug)
Seminar
Workshop: Standardization (or lack thereof) and its impact on global
cultures.
Readings completed:
- Determining Information Needs of Civic Organzations and Voluntary Groups. by
Jerry S. Kidd, [reader]
- Community Communication Patterns by Robin D. Crickman [reader]
- Public Space in Cyberspace (Libraries for the Future), Doug Schuler and
Jamie McClelland,
http://www.lff.org/advocacy/technology/public/
- Information and Communication (chapter from New Community Networks), Doug
Schuler,
http://www.scn.org/civic/ncn/ch_7.html
- Communication as the Root of Scientific Progress (excerpt), Joshua Lederberg
[Internet Dreams, pp 39 - 54]
- Libraries Are More than Information: Situational Aspects of Electronic
Libraries (excerpt), Vicky Reich and Mark Weiser [Internet Dreams, pp 83 - 94]
- The Electronic Capture and Dissemination of the Cultural Practice of
Tibetan Thangka Painting (excerpt), Ranjit Makkuni [Internet Dreams, 95 - 107]
- Digital Reference Rooms: Access to Historical and Cultural Dimensions of
Knowledge; Kim H. Veltman,
http://www.isoc.org/inet99/proceedings/2b/2b_1.htm
Assignments due:
- Journal entry #6: Problems -- old and new -- associated with new network
resource use
[9] Wednesday, February 23, 2000 -- Digital Libraries
Computer Literacy meeting #3
Group project meetings
Workshop: Community information seeking (and advice for librarians)
Readings completed:
- Introduction [Internet Dreams, pp xiii - xxiv]
- The Digital Library Metaphor: The I-Way as Publishing and Community Memory
[Internet Dreams, pp 1 - 14]
- As We May Think" Vannevar Bush Excerpt from Libraries of the Future
(excerpt), J. C. R. Licklider [Internet Dreams, pp 15 - 22]
- The Electronic Mail Metaphor: The I-Way As a Communications Medium [Internet
Dreams, pp 109 - 124]
- Some Consequences of Electronic Groups. Lee Sproull and Samer Faraj
[Internet Dreams, pp 125 - 134]
Assignments due:
- Journal entry #7: How can libraries become active agents for social
amelioration?
[10] Wednesday, March 1, 2000 - Implications
Plato lecture: "Librarians Crossing the Line!
Community Connections: Libraries and the Digital Divide,"
Ann Bishop, University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign
Seminar
Readings completed:
- Digital Communications and the Conduct of Science: The New Literacy
(excerpt), Joshua Lederberg [Internet Dreams, pp 161 - 172]
- Electronic Markets and Electronic Hierarchies (excerpt), Thomas W. Malone,
Joanne Yates, and Robert I. Benjamin [Internet Dreams, pp 191 - 206]
- Slaves of a New Machine: Exploring the For-Free/For-Pay Conundrum, Laura
Fillmore [Internet Dreams, pp 207 - 218]
- Excerpt from "Toward Portable Ideas (excerpt), Mark Stefik and John Seely
Brown [Internet Dreams, pp 327 - 344]
Assignments due:
- Research paper due
- Journal entry #8: How do libraries differ from other types of information
and communication media?
[11] Saturday, March 4, 2000 - Media and Libraries
Guest Speaker: Jimmy Mateson, Media Island, Olympia
Seminar
student presentations
Potluck
Workshop: Media comparisons
Readings completed:
- Landmines in the Understanding Field, Richard Saul Wurman [reader]
- For Sale: Schools, Libraries, Information, Elections, Herbert Schiller
[reader]
- Tlon, Uqbar, Orbis Tertius, Jorge Luis Borges, [reader]
Assignments due:
- Description of individual roles in group projects
[12] Wednesday, March 8, 2000 - Libraries for the Future
Student presentations
What is a library now? What will it be in the Future?? What will we do?
Program debriefing
Readings completed:
Assignments due:
- Field studies (two libraries comparison) report
- Computer fluency final product
- Portfolio